Speaking of Smith

Adam Smith and the Knowledge Problem

division of labor specialization presumption of liberty torpor of the mind

Jon Murphy for AdamSmithWorks

...the division of labor means a division of knowledge.
If you ask anyone what Adam Smith is known for, the likely answer (other than the invisible hand) would be “division of labor.” He begins The Wealth of Nations with a bold statement of his thesis: “The greatest improvement in the productive powers of labour, and the greater part of the skill, dexterity, and judgment with which it is any where directed or applied, seem to have been the effects of the division of labour” (13). He extends the lessons of the pin factory into his support for international trade. 

 But, some 770 pages later, Smith makes an essential qualification. The division of labor can lead to a narrowing of the mind. Smith writes:
In the progress of the division of labour, the employment of the far greater part of those who live by labour…comes to be confined to a few very simple operations…the man whose whole life is spent in performing a few simple operations…has no occasion to exert his understanding, or to exercise his invention in finding out expedients for removing difficulties which never occur (781-782).

Much of the scholarship on this passage focuses on Smith’s discussion of education and how some state-provided education can help offset the adverse effects of the division of labor. However, I wish to focus on a different implication of Smith’s comment: the division of labor means a division of knowledge.

In the passage quoted above, Smith is making explicit something that is implicit throughout his earlier discussion in Book I on the division of labor: as we become specialized in our tasks, we continue to acquire knowledge in those tasks. However, that increasingly specialized knowledge comes at the expense of other types of knowledge out there. The man who draws the wire for a pin may have lots of knowledge and information about pin wire. He may be able to tell quality or know the limitations of the material he is given. But that knowledge comes at the expense of knowing how to create the head. In our modern language, we call such specialized knowledge “expertise.” Thus, there is a trade-off to the division of labor (and, consequently, the division of knowledge): “[The laborer’s] dexterity at his own particular trade seems…to be acquired at the expence [sic] of his intellectual, social, and martial virtues” (782). This “torpor of the mind” that develops from doing the same tasks day-in and day-out can render a man incapable of judging the needs and extensive interests of his country, as well as other civic-minded needs.

In connection with previous statements Smith made elsewhere in The Wealth of Nations, this discussion of the division of knowledge is interesting. For example, in Book IV, Smith writes: “What is the species of domestick [sic] industry which [the businessman’s] capital can employ, and of which the produce is likely to be of the greatest value, every individual, it is evident, can, in his local situation, judge much better than any statesman or lawgiver can do for him” (456). Typically this passage is interpreted in light of the sentences that follow, where Smith contends that such actions by statesmen to direct economic activity both “loads himself with a most unnecessary attention” and “assume[s] an authority which could safely be trusted, not only to no single person, but to no council or senate whatever.” However, the division of knowledge Smith discusses in Book V as a consequence provides us with another understanding of Smith’s concerns. The statesman does not have the necessary knowledge to direct capital; the local owner, though the division of knowledge, is in a better knowledge situation to judge. 

The statesman or ambassador is meant to serve political ends. They are “insidious and crafty” (468). When those guiles are applied to negotiations with foreign nations and the statesman is able to “dupe” the foreign minister, he is to be applauded (Theory of Moral Sentiments, 154). Thus, their specialized knowledge is directed toward those political ends. In politics, that knowledge is valuable. In commerce and civil society, the knowledge of guile is dangerous: “We trust the man who seems willing to trust us…Reserve and concealment, on the contrary, call forth diffidence. We are afraid to follow the man who is going we do not know where” (TMS, 337). 

The Theory of Moral Sentiments also shows concern about the division of knowledge leading to undesired outcomes. For example, Smith discusses how a soldier who is used to submitting to the “disagreeable duty” of war can lose his principle of humanity (153). The soldier may be the model of self-command, but he lacks the necessary humanity that allows civilization to thrive. The soldier knows war; he does not know peace.

The division of labor implies a division of knowledge. That division of knowledge can render a man incapable of judging the needs of society to the extent that they are beyond his specialized area of expertise. But the fact that an individual may be unknowledgeable outside his area of expertise does not, for Smith, imply the need for some centralized agent. He recognizes multiple times that politicians can suffer the same problems. Thus, Smith relies heavily on a presumption of liberty: let men operate in the manner that allows them to best direct their efforts wherever they can be profitably deployed. With their unique power to violate the rules of justice, governments ought only to intervene when necessary. They, too, are limited in their cognitive abilities. They, too, exist within a world of the division of knowledge. They, too, benefit from such a division but can also suffer from a “torpor of the mind.”

Related Links
Michael Munger, Division of Labor Part 3: The System of Exchange
An Animal That Trades video series, Part 3: Division of Labor 
Jack Weinstein, Adam Smith on Education: Schooling
Jon Murphy, Adam Smith and the Presumption of Liberty
Add a comment
Never shown anywhere
Sign in

Unexpected Insights of David Hume

Edwin van de Haar for AdamSmithWorks

His ideas were like those of his younger friend
Adam Smith, but Hume did not write a huge and influential book such as Smith’s The Wealth of Nations (1776). Nevertheless, it should not be overlooked that his economic ideas were put in print long before Smith’s. 

Rose Wilder Lane and the American Libertarian Movement

Alice Temnick for AdamSmithWorks

In Part II of her review of Caroline Fraser's
Prairie Fires, Alice Temnick explores the life and personality of Rose Wilder Lane, daughter of the author of the Little House on the Prairie books.

Adam Smith and the Highlanders

Renee Wilmeth for AdamSmithWorks

The Outlander Kitchen: The Official Outlander Companion Cookbookfeatures a simple Cock-a-leekie soup, a classic chicken soup with vegetables that’s been a Scottish classic since at least the 17th century. The first recipes for a chicken leek soup appeared before it was ever named “Cock-a-Leekie” which didn’t appear until the late 18th century.  

Adam Smith and Kidney Exchange

Walter Castro and Julio J. Elías for AdamSmithWorks

Castro and Elías return with more Smithian insights into the logic of altruism and the design of kidney exchange markets.

The Singular Significance to Smith of Claude Buffier

Graham McAleer for AdamSmithWorks

In this post, Professor McAleer shows how Claude Buffier (a "learned Jesuit") influenced Smith's axiology, or his study of the nature of value and valuation. 

Moral Sentiments, Active and Passive

Daniel B. Klein for AdamSmithWorks
June 21, 2021

Klein walks us through Adam Smith's implicit distinction between active and passive moral sentiments.

Free Trade in Language: Adam Smith on Words and Wine

Sarah Skwire for AdamSmithWorks

Since Smith was clearly at peace with the idea of importing French wines, why does he object to importing French words?

FDR versus Liberalism: Quotations from David Green, 1987

Daniel B. Klein for AdamSmithWorks
June 3, 2021

In this post, economist Daniel B. Klein unpacks the relationship between President Franklin D. Roosevelt and the meaning of the word "liberalism," drawing on David Green's 1987 book, The Language of Politics in America: Shaping Political Consciousness from McKinley to Reagan.

Adam Smith in the Narrow Corridor

Shanon FitzGerald for AdamSmithWorks

Adam Smith understood that freedom is not the natural order of things. Do we?

Adam Smith's Lost Loves

Enrique Guerra-Pujol for AdamSmithWorks

Did Adam Smith know what it was like to be in love? Here's a law professor's primer on the evidence.

Smith on Rousseau

Daniel B. Klein for AdamSmithWorks
May 3, 2021

In this video, Daniel B. Klein speaks about the historical and intellectual relationship between Adam Smith and Jean-Jacques Rousseau. 

Adam Smith and the Market for Kidneys for Transplantation

Walter Castro and Julio J. Elías for AdamSmithWorks

Could the kidney transplantation system benefit from an injection of Adam Smith's ideas? Authors Castro and Elias, drawing on research published with Gary Becker, share their analysis below. 

Adam Smith y Política Fiscal

Thelmo Vargas-Madrigal for AdamSmithWorks

Costa Rican economist Thelmo Vargas-Madrigal explains the relevance of Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations to modern discussions of public policy and the provision of public goods. 

Adam Smith on Fiscal Policy

Thelmo Vargas-Madrigal for AdamSmithWorks

Costa Rican economist Thelmo Vargas-Madrigal explains the relevance of Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations to modern discussions of public policy and the provision of public goods. 

Adam Smith on the Interests of Labor and Business

Alex Aragona for AdamSmithWorks

According to Smith, to understand business economics we need to see that both labor and business should be recognized as classes, and that both pursue separate interests and agendas that sometimes conflict.

Adam Smith on Political Parties

Max Skjönsberg for AdamSmithWorks

Smith had both understanding of and insight into political parties, and while he spoke candidly about their harmful effects, he also believed that they could play an important role in reforming abuse and securing tranquility and happiness in the state.

Benevolence, Beneficence, and Beneficialness

Daniel B. Klein for AdamSmithWorks
March 15, 2021

What do these "three B's" have to do with the sentiment of gratitude? Daniel B. Klein explains. 

How to Read a Book Inspectionally

Art Carden for AdamSmithWorks

Inspectional reading is a tool that can make us better readers, scholars, and lifelong learners.

Devoured by Wild Beasts or Drowned Like Puppies? With Markets, Neither

Maria Pia Paganelli for AdamSmithWorks

Adam Smith understood that prosperity decreases desperation and spares the lives of many infants, older persons, and vulnerable others who cannot participate directly in production. Have today's critics of markets forgotten this lesson?

Smithian Exchange Among Non-Human Animals

James E. Hanley for AdamSmithWorks

Smith wrote about the human propensity to "truck, barter, and exchange," but the modern science of animal behavior suggests that we are not exactly alone in this capability. 

The Moon Phase Watch and Adam Smith’s Philosophy of History

Graham McAleer for AdamSmithWorks
Does Smith's philosophy of history give in to the apocalyptic temptation to "immanentize the eschaton"? A clue it does not is the moon phase watch. 

Adam Smith, Francis Fukuyama, and the Indignity of UBI

Thomas Koenig for AdamSmithWorks

UBI does not speak to the demands of dignity, nor to the Smithian needs to be seen and respected. 

Bargaining with the Butcher, Baker, and Brewer: A New Look at Smith’s Most Famous Sentences

Jacob Sider Jost for AdamSmithWorks

Our desire to persuade each other is not reducible to our pursuit of self-interest in a narrow material sense; it is rather a deep feature of human nature, one we share with the men and women whom we rely on for our food.

Profitable Business: Adam Smith’s Moral Assessment

Gregory Robson for AdamSmithWorks

What we get in Smith is not a utopian view of profitable business, but a humane and realistic assessment of the power of firms and the markets in which they operate to do good in the world.

What Adam Smith Ate: Christmas Punch

Renee Wilmeth for AdamSmithWorks

Smith would have enjoyed his favorite claret, what we would call Bordeaux today, as well as, perhaps, a Christmas punch. 

Adam Smith Wishes You a Mereology Christmas

Graham McAleer for AdamSmithWorks

Aristotle’s proposition that individuals belong more to the republic than to themselves folds the part (individual) into the whole (polity). This mereology collapsed, argues Strauss, when people adopted the Christian belief in a personal transcendent destiny and a loyalty to a kingdom beyond this world.

Happiness in Times of Crisis

Garret Edwards for AdamSmithWorks

By François Topino-Lebrun - Public Domain

"In highlighting the anecdote of Pyrrhus and Cineas, Smith moves away from an answer to the happiness question that is merely economic or material."

Adam Smith Wants you to ENJOY the Holidays

James E. Hartley for AdamSmithWorks

...the holidays are coming and the goose is getting…dropped from the menu. Multiply that by all those things you used to do and will not be doing this year, and it all seems rather bleak. But, why? Why aren’t you excited that your forthcoming celebrations are going to be novel and different?

Adam Smith’s Readers in Eighteenth-Century Libraries

Max Skjönsberg for AdamSmithWorks

One way to investigate the broader impact of Smith’s writings is through the lens of eighteenth-century subscription libraries. 

Adam Smith on the Emergent Meaning of “Stuff”

Lauren Hall for AdamSmithWorks

While it’s not in the nature of Smith to wax too philosophical over human meaning, I think his treatment of property, combined with the themes of spontaneous order and emergent meaning that thread their way throughout his work, can help us come to terms with and understand the role that property or “stuff” plays in our lives and why it matters.

Adam Smith: Myths and Realities

Brianne Wolf for AdamSmithWorks

LF capitalist.jpg 36.33 KB

August 31, 2020 

The Sympathetic Businessman

Jon Murphy for AdamSmithWorks

July 17, 2020

Maugham's story is worth a read for entertainment, but it also highlights an important aspect of commerce: the necessity of sympathy. 

Adam Smith and the Costs of the Division of Labor

Alex Aragona for AdamSmithWorks

July 3, 2020

One shouldn’t be satisfied with any discussion of the division of labor that leaves consideration of the costs off the table. 

The Hopeful Vision of Saint Augustine and Adam Smith

Kenly Stewart for AdamSmithWorks

June 22, 2020

Here I use Tertullian’s formula to ask a different question, “What has Glasgow to do with Hippo?”

"Saving Adam Smith" Saves My Economics Class

Leah Kilfoyle for AdamSmithWorks

June 19, 2020

Saving Adam Smith hit the bullseye for my most recent search for a book that not only covers a number of my state’s standards, but demystifies the broader understanding of Adam Smith’s economics.

Joseph Banks

Carl Oberg for AdamSmithWorks

June 15, 2020

"...Banks, perhaps instinctively, knew more about economic change than his educational and scientific background let on."

Adam Smith and Jane Austen

Renee Wilmeth for AdamSmithWorks

June 5, 2020

The similarities in Smith’s descriptions of moral weakness and Austen’s descriptions of people were undeniable. It was as if I could assign a different character in the book to each of Smith’s passages on moral philosophy.

The East Asian economic miracle: An iron hand, or an invisible one?

Rob York for AdamSmithWorks

May 18, 2020

A great leader isn’t necessary for great results, and an invisible hand beats an iron one any day. 

Fighting COVID-19 with Pretty Machines

Rachel Lomasky for AdamSmithWorks

May 4, 2020

Today’s machines are even prettier than the cleverly rigged piece of rope Smith admires. They are robots that help enable the prosperity of modern society. And during this time of global epidemic, their result is more than mere diversion.

The 18th Century and Social Networking

Carl Oberg for AdamSmithWorks

April 27, 2020

“...The mirth of … company is highly agreeable to him, and he regards this correspondence of their sentiments with his own as the greatest applause.”

Pro-Slavery, Anti-Smith

Timothy Sandefur for AdamSmithWorks

March 16, 2020

It’s unlikely that Burke imagined, when sneering at “economists” in his Reflections, that his defense of feudal hierarchy would later serve as the foundation for a bloody rebellion aimed at perpetuating chattel slavery.

What Would Adam Smith Say About Fasting?

Nathanael Snow for AdamSmithWorks

March 9, 2020

To become willing to share bread with the hungry and to enter into solidarity with the suffering of others requires the activation of what Adam Smith calls sympathy, the ability to enter into another person’s sentiments through imagining one’s self in her place.

Adam Smith in the Car and in the Classroom

Andrew Smith for AdamSmithWorks

February 24, 2020

“Dad, what if there were no money? What if we could have everything we wanted and not have to pay for it?” 

The Future of Farmers – Adam Smith Weighs In

Paul Schwennesen for AdamSmithWorks

February 17, 2020

The ailment, clearly, is not affecting farming, but farmers, historically understood. Our issue is a social one, not a technical one.

The Imitative Arts: Some Fun with Adam Smith’s Artistic Opinions

Maryann Corbett for AdamSmithWorks

January 13, 2020

In his essay on the arts, Smith says much that now looks wrong, but his questionable claims might be the most interesting things he has to say.

Adam Smith and Slavery

Matthew Lowenstein for AdamSmithWorks

December 2, 2019

...is he right on the economics? That is, are there instances when slave labor could, at least conceptually, more effectively mobilize and accumulate capital than free labor? 

Can We Become the Impartial Spectator?

Nir Ben-Moshe for AdamSmithWorks

November 11, 2019

To what extent did Smith believe we can become the impartial spectator?

A Modern Lawyer and Smith’s Lectures on Jurisprudence, Part 2

Clark Neily for AdamSmithWorks

October 7, 2019

Ensuring justice in a complex world is a daunting task. But it is the fundamental duty and the true raison d’etre of every sovereign, every elected body, and every legitimate political regime of whatever character or constitution.