1. Life & Times
  2. Speaking of Smith

Speaking of Smith

Nobody's Perfect, Not Even Adam Smith

Shal Marriott for AdamSmithWorks

"...no matter how much we love his work, no matter how worthy of our admiration and praise that work is, we need to be careful not to become blinded by our fondness and enthusiasm for it."
When you find a piece of writing that speaks to you, it is easy to become consumed by it--to admire it with such enthusiasm, that it becomes idealized. When we encounter works like this, they become touchpoints that we revisit frequently, that we enter into a dialogue with, and that fascinate us endlessly with the questions they inspire.

For many of us, some of those cherished pieces of writing are written by Adam Smith. But no matter how much we love his work, no matter how worthy of our admiration and praise that work is, we need to be careful not to become blinded by our fondness and enthusiasm for it. This becomes more true the more time we spend studying him and the more his works speak to us. As we become increasingly invested in the works we spend our time with, we become more partial to them and that can affect our judgement. That bias in their favor can lead us to the temptation to overlook their imperfections, to make excuses at times when we should be critical, and to let things go that in other cases we would question. We fail when we forget that an author’s flaws are just as important as their achievements.

Thus the fiercest defenders of Adam Smith and his legacy ought also to be among his harshest critics. It sounds contradictory, in a way. Why should we be critical of the person we are trying to defend? Because that’s the very purpose of inquiry. Good scholarship is not about assuming we are right, but testing to see if we are wrong. That applies from the principles of physics right through to the Theory of Moral Sentiments. 

When it comes to Adam Smith, it’s crucial that our conversations are not simply about how lovely his world is, but about the ways in which it is not. Even if we don’t always like the answers we might find, we need to take the time in our considerations to play the part of the critic. We also need to remember when introducing people to his work  that we cannot ask them to be open minded and consider changing their minds about him if we ourselves are not willing to do the same.  

Adam Smith is a thinker who has inspired many, and it hasn’t always been out of love. Consider the ways in which Smith influenced one of his greatest critics, Karl Marx. He has also had a positive influence for many people, who see a lot of good within the writings he has left behind. For many here on this site, Adam Smith really has changed our lives for the better (Russ Roberts even wrote a book about it). 

But I write as someone who is already in love with Smith’s work, who has been convinced of his ideas. For those who are not, for those who think he has gotten a lot wrong, or that he should be merely a footnote in history, come join the conversation and explore those ideas. Help me be a better critic, and hopefully I can help you to see some good in what he has to offer.

Reading Smith means entering into a dialogue with him and all those who have explored his thoughts. It means exploring different sides of his arguments, different perspectives on his principles, and different ideas about how they apply to our world. That kind of dialogue also allows us to connect to one another, a thought Smith would have been fond of I imagine. 




* Readers may also be interested in Pedro Schwartz, What Karl Marx Did and Did Not See in Adam Smith.

Comments
Add a comment
Never shown anywhere
Or
Sign in

Adam Smith and Stadial Theory

John Burrow for AdamSmithWorks

Not only was this Stadial Theory of civilization helpful for understanding history and the past, it also allowed Smith to make sense of Scotland’s political, economic, and social transformations in the 18th century.

The Imitative Arts: Some Fun with Adam Smith’s Artistic Opinions

Maryann Corbett for AdamSmithWorks

In his essay on the arts, Smith says much that now looks wrong, but his questionable claims might be the most interesting things he has to say.

The Unexpected Joy in Sharing Sadness

Shal Marriott for AdamSmithWorks

There are many lessons to be taken away from The Theory of Moral Sentiments... Yet an unexpected but important takeaway, is that we all should take a little bit more time to be sad.

Isn’t It Odd? The Project on Smith, Hume, Liberalism and Esotericism

Dan Klein for AdamSmithWorks

Adam Smith on the Country-City Debate

What is the "best place" to live- the city or the country?

by Sarah Skwire for AdamSmithWorks

Eastern Science, Individualism, and Adam Smith

by Mike Young for AdamSmith

Smith’s unique belief in the individual results in a surprisingly modern assessment of Islamic contributions to astronomy.

How Did Adam Smith Think About History?


by Mike Young for AdamSmithWorks

Adam Smith Visits Downton Abbey

by Shal Marriott for AdamSmithWorks

Sir William Lucas Should Have Read Adam Smith

by Sarah Skwire

Etiquette and Adam Smith

by Candace Smith for AdamSmithWorks

Money and Virtue in the Ancient World

with Sarah Skwire

What would Adam Smith think about your iPhone?

with Sarah Skwire

Why do we Admire Celebrities?

with Jon Murphy

Adam Smith and "The Office"

with Dylan DelliSanti

Take Time to See the Harmony

with Amy Willis

What Would Adam Smith Think of My Weekend?

with Sarah Skwire

On First Looking into The Wealth Of Nations

How does a student of poetry come to love Smithian political economy? Sarah Skwire counts the ways...

Smith and Superheroes

with your scholar-hosts Sarah Skwire and Aeon Skoble
Editor's Note: Please help us maintain this as a NO SPOILER space. References up to and including Infinity Wars and Captain Marvel are acceptable, but please no spoilers for Endgame. Thank you!

What Makes Man Sociable?

Amy Willis for AdamSmithWorks

What makes people naturally sociable? How do we come to together as a community or society?

Smith's Scientific Milestones

with your scholar-host, Graham McAleer*

In this piece we consider the possible impact of major events in the sciences upon Adam Smith’s thought.  

Adam Smith and the Presumption of Liberty

with your scholar-host Jon Murphy*


Adam Smith was no anarchist. Smith did have a strong presumption of liberty, but this presumption was not absolute. Under certain conditions, a jural superior (such as a sovereign or magistrate) could violate this presumption of liberty and impose a policy that would break the rules of justice.

Drama versus Data- Adam Smith on Description

People simply don’t respond to data the way they do to drama. Adam Smith—economist and professor of rhetoric—was ideally equipped to understand and explain why.

Is love ridiculous???

Is Love Ridiculous???
with Professor Spyridon Tegos


Ridicule does not seem to be an indifferent topic for Adam Smith. In this respect, he dedicates two of his Lectures on Rhetoric and Belles Lettres, (numbers 9 and 10) in which we read that while we admire the grand and beautiful and show contempt to what is mean and little...

Art's Important Moral Work

With Professor Graham McAleer

Adam Smith had a life-long interest in the arts.  He was surely a man of taste.  However, his biographer, Dugald Stewart, suggests Smith’s interest in the arts and fashion was primarily “on account of their connexion with the general principles of the human mind” (Essays on Philosophical Subjects, 173).  Smith, it seems, was ever the theorist.  

Beauty and Language in Adam Smith

with Zaccheus Harmon

The 18th century is generally cited as the birthplace of modern aesthetic thought. Whatever the veracity of this claim, there is little doubt that aesthetic topics were central to the intellectual projects of Enlightenment in a way that was unprecedented in the immediately preceding centuries. Philosophers and critics writing during this period addressed themselves to a variety of aesthetic questions: What is the nature of taste? How are aesthetic judgments made and what justifies such judgments? What is the nature of the beautiful and how does it relate to other aesthetic qualities, such as the sublime or the picturesque? What is the nature of artistic representation and how does it relate to the beauty of the natural world?

Adam Smith is no exception to this trend. Although he produced no systematic treatise on aesthetics (or “criticism” as it was called among Eighteenth century Brits), Smith touches on these issues at a number of places in his work. In the following series of blog posts, I want to examine some of Smith’s most insightful and interesting comments on aesthetic topics.